Who Am I to Judge (Best Memphis Burger Fest)?

I felt like a kid on Christmas morning when I woke up today.

Knowing I would be a judge at the 2013 Best Memphis Burger Fest had that effect on me. I had already picked out what I was wearing, made sure my camera batteries were charged and knew the directions to Minglewood Hall where BMBF13 was being held.

I washed down half of a Gibson’s cinnamon roll with some coffee and paced around the apartment as I waited for Tammy to get ready. The more I waited, the more nervous I got.

Showing off my BMBF13 “outfit,” judges pass & trophies.

Showing off my BMBF13 “outfit,” judges pass & trophies.

When I get nervous I have to pee and I went twice before we left the apartment then again as soon as we got to Minglewood Hall.

We had arrived about 45 minutes before Seth (aka Mr. Best Memphis Burger) said I needed to be at the judges tent and I peed two times before I got my judges pass.

The smells coming from the parking lot were unbelievable. It was like a giant tailgating party with tents set up every few feet and smoke billowing from every grill.

BMBF13_TeamsSome of the tents were giving away samples, but even though my stomach was growling, I decided to wait until AFTER the judging was over.

I headed over to the judges tent and found a spot at a table in the far back corner. I was judging in the Anything But Beef category, which wasn’t the same thing as Vegetarian.


That’s me in the far right corner.

Other judges starting coming in and two girls ended up sitting at my table.

I was too nervous to tinker with my phone like my table-mates.

I was too nervous to tinker with my phone like my table-mates.

They explained the scoring and said we would each be getting four burgers. For a few seconds I thought I was going to be getting FIVE burgers because there were so many entries, but only ended up with four.

Once everyone at the table had four burgers we could open our boxes and start judging.

Let the judging begin.

Let the judging begin.

I opened my first boxed and peered inside. It was a crab cake burger with BBQ potato chips on it. Part of it was falling out of the bun so I had to scoop it up in order to stop it from spilling completely out, all of which resulted in a loss of presentation points. It had a really good taste and was definitely something I would eat again.

While I was inspecting, eating and judging my crab cake, the girl next to me had dug into her first box, taken a bite and wasn’t feeling too good. She was sitting there with her hand over her mouth, staring blankly ahead. The other girl at the table asked if she was OK.

She shook her head, her hand still covering her mouth, jumped up, stood in the grass behind us and threw up.

You think she liked her first bite?

You think she liked her first bite?

We stood there watching her, offering to help as she ridded herself of the bite. She sat back down, apologized profusely to us and the judging officials, saying she’s never done that before.

They asked if she was OK to continue judging and, to her credit, she plowed through her remaining boxes without any problems. She said the only thing she could think of was that she didn’t like the consistency. That’s really all she said about it.

She had eaten out of Box #1, which was also sitting in front of me. As if I wasn’t already nervous enough…

The presentation inside the second box was amazing. I only wish I had thought about taking pictures of my boxes.

The top of the bun had a portabella mushroom covered in marinara sauce. The bottom of the bun was almost like a meatball with a thick layer of mozzarella cheese. I put the two sides together and dug in.


Little did I know it, but it was definitely the best of my four options. There were so many layers of flavor that I had to make myself NOT eat more of it.

To the victor go the spoils.

To the victor go the spoils.

My third box was a spicy falafel inside of a pita with feta cheese and tzatziki sauce. It was spicier than I expected but had good enough flavor that I actually took TWO bites.

I saved Box #1 for last. The box contained three turkey burger sliders. I grabbed one, inspected it and nervously took a bite, hoping it wouldn’t make me puke.

The turkey patty was tender, but didn’t have a lot of flavor. All I could taste was the bacon under the patty, but the bacon wasn’t crisp at all. It was way undercooked and the fatty part of the bacon was stringy. Even though it didn’t made me sick, I could see how it could have.

We were told we could take our leftovers with us, something I had been wondering about all week, and of course I took mine with me.

Even though I was done, I didn’t want to leave and stuck around to watch the rest of the judging, the kids pickle eating and the Kookamonga eating contests.

The contestants for the kids pickle eating contest.

The contestants for the kids pickle eating contest.


Trying the double-fisting techinque.

Kids 12 and under lined up and the first ones to eat all three pickles won trophies.


About to have a “Reversal of Fortune.”

About to have a “Reversal of Fortune.”



The Extreme Burgers




The Kookamunga Challenge

Teams of two tackled the 4-pound Kookamunger burger from the Kooky Canuck.

THE Kooky Canuck.

THE Kooky Canuck.


BMBF13_KookamongaChallengeBMBF13_KookamongaChallenge2BMBF13_KookamongaChallenge3The aftermath…


The Winners

Bloody Mary

  1. Burgernado
  2. Patrick’s
  3. AS Martin & Buns


  1. Burgers Elevan
  2. U.S. Foods
  3. Meat in the Middle

Anything But Beef

  1. Pirates of the Grillabean
  2. Burgers Elevan
  3. Burgernado


  1. Burgernado
  2. Blood, Sweat and Beef
  3. Beef Street Flippa’s

Best Memphis Burger

  1. BMBF13_TrophyBurger Deacons
  2. U.S. Foods
  3. Meat in the Middle

Unfortunately I have no way of knowing if any of the four Anything But Beef burgers I ate finished in the Top 3.

But in the end it doesn’t really matter because I had a blast. I was so honored to have been asked to be a judge after having been in the area since February. I hope to be invited back in 2014 and for years to come.

This entry was posted in Daily Life, Food and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Who Am I to Judge (Best Memphis Burger Fest)?

  1. muddledmom says:

    That sounds like fun. Man, those extreme burgers live up to their names. Yowza.

  2. Matt Gatewood says:

    The anything but that you liked was from team Burgernado. It ended up taking third. Next year, you need to join us and see it from the other side. It is one of the most fun days of the year!

  3. Pingback: My Food Bucket List (Update #1) | The Life of J-Wo

  4. Pingback: Things I Have Overheard Pt XX | The Life of J-Wo

  5. Pingback: Debut of “The Hungry Curmedgeon” | The Life of J-Wo

  6. Pingback: My experience at Best Memphis Burger Fest | The Life of J-Wo

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s